Neal McDonough

Skip

Sean Astin

Whitmer

Kelly Stables

Connie

Caylee Cowan

Christina Christmas

James Maslow

Sam

Brian Thomas Smith

Boogie

Emily Tosta

Brooke

Ava Jean

Holiday Dancer (credited as Ava Jean Cutlip)

Haley Reinhart

Anna

Abby Miller

Choreographer

Selah Victor

Pregnant Spa Client

Montana Tucker

Cheryl

Bradley Evans

Dr. Andrew

Hugh Sheridan

George

Sadie Stratton

Jennifer Neilson

Tess Murphy

Stella

Jeff Rector

Vance Jordan

Bastiano Ferrari

Phillip (credited under a different name)

London Stubblefield

Holiday Shopper

Stephanie Garvin

Melanie

Lars Slind

John

Callan Barry

Henry

Kelly Mi Li

Amanda

Melody Thornton

Brenda

Adi Ben Ezra

Yogi

Hudson Barry

Stuart

Sydney McCarthy

Joy

Berkeley James

Brianna

Pierre Abena

Fireman

Adam Khattar

Ezra

Jasmine Rossi

Jessica

Kevin A. Carter

Delivery Man

Kellen Patino

Brant

Holly Holder

Bridesmaid

Blake Leeper

Santa Rex

Aly Rozdilsky

Dancer

Margo Della-Guardia

Nicole

Jenelle Hardwick

Nurse

Jake Miller

Kyle

Kristen Louelle Gaffney

Molly

Kayla Folgar

Connie's Sister

Scarlett Petty

Dancer

Patrick Mylett

Groomsmen

Deborah Pelant

Helena

Parker Logie

Stephen

Isabelle Young

Young Connie

Billy Kloser

Caroler

Anthony Arrigo

Massage Therapist / Party Guest (uncredited)

Jason Jno-lewis

Emergency Medical Technician (uncredited)

Kamilla Shimina

Caroler kid (uncredited)

Ofir Sofer

Yogi (uncredited)