Anna Colvin

Kimberly (segment "A Shitty Visit")

Neil Wolfman

Earl (segment "A Shitty Visit)"

Matías Kruse

Steve (segment "The Shittiest Advice Known to Man"

Jacob Israel

Man in Stall (segment "The Shittiest Advice Known to Man")

Quinton Nash

Manager (segment "The Shittiest Advice Known to Man")

Jude Kilumbu

The Shitposter (segment "The Shitposter")

Caleb McKnabb

Craig (segment "The Shitposter")

Aidan Roche

Jamie (segment "When Shit Hits the Fan")

Eric Canfield

Sam (segment "When Shit Hits the Fan")

Grace Woosley

Lex (segment "When Shit Hits the Fan")

Will Lampe

Rick (segment "When Shit Hits the Fan")

Seth Williams

Dante (segment "Shit Stain")

Sanath Hegde

Jimmy (segment "Shit Stain")

Alexander Ekker

The Person With No Name (segment "Shit Stain")

Caleb M. Jordan

Dave (segment "Shit Stain") [voice]

Erika Sharp

Mary (segment "Shit Stain") [voice]

Casey Barnes

Tommy the Toilet Bowl Poop Inspector